Ganga’s Dilemma

The Aviral Ganga, symbolising a continuous, unhindered flow, now grapples with a dilemma as developmental projects promise potential and at the same time challenge its unbroken journey.

The unfortunate truth persists: environmental concerns are often not accorded the same national priority as development and growth. This paradox is vividly illustrated by the River Ganga, a potent metaphor for the interplay between Environment and Development. The Ganges, India’s holiest river, has seen its natural course disrupted by dams, hydropower projects, and irrigation systems driven by economic growth objectives. While pursuing development, these efforts have disrupted the river’s flow, altering its ecology and affecting communities.

The poignant question emerges: Is the Ganga still the Aviral Ganga it once embodied, or has development fragmented its essential flow?

Base map of northern India, Nepal, Bangladesh and the Bay of Bengal. The Ganga basin with the four largest dams marked a, b, c and d along the river's course.

In profile

Four structures, one river

Profile of the Tehri Dam drawn to relative scale.
a

Tehri Dam

Uttarakhand · on the Bhagirathi

Dam — stores water behind it

100% relative height, as drawn

India’s tallest dam, and the structure this project follows.

Profile of the Bhimgoda Barrage drawn to relative scale.
b

Bhimgoda Barrage

Haridwar, Uttarakhand

Barrage — regulates and diverts flow

30% relative height, as drawn

The first structure the river meets after leaving the hills.

Profile of the Narora Barrage drawn to relative scale.
c

Narora Barrage

Uttar Pradesh

Barrage — regulates and diverts flow

34% relative height, as drawn

Out on the plains, along the river’s most populous stretch.

Profile of the Farakka Barrage drawn to relative scale.
d

Farakka Barrage

West Bengal

Barrage — regulates and diverts flow

59% relative height, as drawn

The last of the four, before the river crosses into Bangladesh.

Profiles are lifted from the original artwork and share one baseline, so their heights compare directly. Positions along the river are indicative.

Why Tehri Dam

In the heart of the majestic Himalayas, an engineering marvel stands as a testament to human ambition and innovation—the Tehri Dam. Stretching across the Bhagirathi River, this colossal structure represents a pinnacle of development, its vast reservoir embodying the power to illuminate cities and irrigate fields

Locator graphic: a globe showing India, linked to a satellite view of Uttarakhand with the Tehri Dam site marked.
Photograph of the Tehri Dam reservoir set among Himalayan hillsides.

Tehri through the times

Understanding the evolution, formation, protest and impact of Indias’ tallest dam which on one hand was constructed for developmental reasons but it impacted the flow of Ganges

1817
1956
1968
1970
1978
1980
to 1998
2002
2003
2006
1817
Portrait of Sudarshan Shah beside an archive photograph of the hillside town of Tehri.

Sudarshan Shah chose Tehri as his capital due to its scenic, secure location surrounded by two rivers.

1956
Archive photograph of a busy street market in Tehri with a signboard reading Tehri, altitude 640 metres.

Market of the city

1968
Archive photographs of Tehri's buildings, gateway and streets with residents going about daily life.

People can be seen in their day to day life

1970
Archive photographs of terraced fields, a roadside shop and a street in Tehri.

People can be seen in their day to day life

1978
Archive photograph of surveyors and earth-moving machinery at the river during the dam survey.

Dam survey and proposal passed

1980 to 1998
Protest photographs: Sunderlal Bahuguna and a fellow activist, a NO DAM wall slogan, a Hindi slogan reading the dam is the destruction of the mountains, and residents demonstrating on a truck.

Continuous resistance and Protest by people and activists such as Sundar Lal Bahuguna

2002
Archive photograph of a bridge partly under water as construction fills the valley.

Construction started and roads and bridges to fill

2003
Photographs of Old Tehri going under water as the reservoir rises.

Submerging town

2006
Photograph of a submerged temple structure standing in the reservoir once the dam was functional.

Dam was functional by 2006

Lost village and its dependents

Interview excerpts of displaced community from Tehri who were at the forefront of effects of Tehri dam construction and will be in the front in case of probable unfortunate collapse

Portrait of Parshram Bhatt, a resident of Old Tehri.
PARSHRAM BHATT
Resident Old Tehri
“The river is just left 20% only now and also,they took away our fruit trees, our lands and displaced us in a wildlife protected area again to be displaced soon after. No sense of community here in Khand. I am also scared of this dam breaking someday”
Portrait of Sushila Negi, Pradhan of the Old Tehri Welfare Society.
SUSHILA NEGI
Pradhaan od Old Tehri Welfare Society, first phase resident
“We were 1st phase residents to be moved from Tehri, survived with no electricity, meagre compensation and wandered from house to house. Where is the development I was promised?”
Portrait of Raani Rawat, a resident of Raiwala.
RAANI RAWAT
Resident Raiwala
“The dam did give opportunities to people but why were they not from Tehri. We were not compensated fairly and lost all ancestral lands. They are kaccha mountains which were bombed for the dam, causing erosion, one day the dam will collapse due to these bombings and landslides”
Displaced almost 100 kms away
Satellite views of Old Tehri, Raiwala and Khaand connected by arrows marked 92.8 kms and 12 km, showing how far residents were displaced.

this fear of dam collapse was repeatedly quoted by our interviewees.

“ What if Tehri Dam breaks ?

So we undertake a speculative journey into the realm of possibility, where it is envisioned the repercussions of such an event. It led to exploring what lies on the other side of the dam’s towering presence.

But to first understand the repercussions, we need to look at the scale, size and expanse of Tehri dam

Height of Tehri Dam

The Tehri Dam’s stature reaches over 260 meters, a testament to human engineering ingenuity. It outstrips even the Statue of Unity, which stands at 182 meters, showcasing both technological achievement and the drive to harness nature’s resources on a monumental scale.

Leaning Tower of Pisa

0metres

The Tehri Dam at 266 metres compared with the Statue of Unity, the Statue of Liberty and the Leaning Tower of Pisa 266 m — dam crest
Stack to the crest

Heights are to scale — one pixel is 5 metres, so each figure rounds to the nearest pixel. Widths are indicative, not measured.

Volume of Tehri Dam

The dam’s reservoir boasts a vast volume, measured in acre-feet—an equivalent of over 1500 Olympic-sized swimming pools combined. This comparison vividly illustrates the immense capacity of the reservoir, exceeding even the largest water bodies we’re familiar with. This volume holds the potential for both development and devastation, underscoring the delicate balance between its promise and peril.

Volumetric Tehri Dam

An isometric box filling with water to represent the reservoir volume

0acre-ft

0of 1,500 Olympic pools

A field of 1,500 tiles, one for every Olympic swimming pool of water

One tile is one Olympic pool — 50 m × 25 m

Laid end to end, those pools run 75 kilometres.

0 42.2 km — a marathon 75 km

1,500 pools × 50 m each — near enough two marathons of swimming lanes, end to end.

Expanse of Tehri Dam

The dam if we compare it to the size of a metro city like Delhi for example can actually shadow the whole city with just its size and expanse.The map of Delhi juxtaposed with the Tehri dam and its size to show the extent of expanse of dam

Satellite view of Delhi with the Tehri reservoir outline and the Yamuna overlaid at the same scale Delhi UT Yamuna Tehri reservoir at the same scale

Three things sit on one satellite view, all at the same scale: the National Capital Territory, the Yamuna running through it, and the Tehri reservoir laid over the top. Pick a layer to isolate it.

Factors affecting
Dams’ possible breakage

1. Seismic activity

The dam is threatened by the various fault lines and the probability of a high magnitude seismic earthquake owing to the past record of such quakes and even the vulnerability of the state of Uttarakhand being in zone 4 and 5

Map of Uttarakhand showing recorded earthquake epicentres, the Himalayan thrust faults, and the position of the Tehri Dam 25 km 50 km 100 km TEHRI DAM

Epicentres and faults as plotted in the original map. The dam is placed from its coordinates against the map’s own scale bar, so its position is approximate.

Major Earthquake timeline in the region

The dam is threatened by the various fault lines and the probability of a high magnitude seismic earthquake owing to the past record of such quakes and even the vulnerability of the state of Uttarakhand being in zone 4 and 5.

A three-storey building taking increasing earthquake damage as magnitude rises

Illustrative: general effects at each magnitude, not a structural model of Tehri.

1803

Epicenter: Garhwal

7.5M

What a magnitude 7.5 can do

Energy released vs. a magnitude 6.5 1.0×
2.Landslides
soil erosion
3.War like
situations
4.Rapid silt
accumulation

What if Tehri collapses

If the Tehri Dam were to collapse, the potential consequences would be severe and widespread due to the massive volume of water stored in its reservoir. Showing the impacts visually on different cities and places if dam collapses

Illustrated map of the flood path after a dam collapse, running from the dam through Devprayag, Rishikesh, Haridwar, Roorkee and Bijnor, annotated 2.6 billion cubic metres of water released and 60 minutes to reach Haridwar.
0 min downstream
60 minutes time taken to reach Haridwar

Every figure below stands for 25,000 people.

Pictogram of 50 human figures, each representing 25,000 people, illustrating the 1.2 million lives affected by flooding and destruction.

What can be done to mitigate?

To mitigate the potential collapse of the Tehri Dam, a multi-pronged strategy is essential

These measures collectively enhance preparedness and response, minimising potential impacts.

Illustration of a house standing in floodwater.

References

Field research photographs from Rishikesh: interviews with residents, a roadside signboard, a shop interior and a resettled house.
Field research, Rishikesh
A data narrative and field research project by Pawan Mishra.